“ Love the ambiance. Great fried tenderloin. Unless you're super hungry, you'll be taking some home. Which was good. Great fries - seasoned and super crispy. Double burger was all it should be. Great meat, fresh veggies and tasty bun. Don't need truffle mayo with this one. I'll be going back. So many good things on the menu to try. ”

“ We watched Sherman doing a morning review at Knuckles and decided to visit the restaurant. I ordered the Hubcap tenderloin and was immediately impressed with the size of not only the tenderloin, but the bun. It ranks right up there with the superb tenderloin of the old Edwards drive-in. Maybe even better. My wife ordered the Reuben sandwich. We switched half of each sandwich with one another. I managed to finish both of my halves, but my wife found that half of the Reuben was enough for her. Both sandwiches were excellent! The hot fries were some of the best we've had. Knuckles gets a 5 for the tastiness of the food and for the friendly staff. We will return to this 50s themed restaurant for it's excellent menu choices. ”

“ We've been to knuckle sandwich several times two times for lunch and once for breakfast, they were all delicious. I wish I'd taken a picture of the hubcap tenderloin it was delicious for breakfast. We had the pancakes which we split. It was plenty for both of us. I would highly recommend you stop in this family, friendly, 50s. style diner. ”

“ A southside institution! I had not been since they moved to the new location in Bargersville, and I was nervous that it would be lacking the nostalgic factor I remembered. I needn't have worried. Everything is still amazing! From the decor, to the music, the amazing and attentive waitstaff, to the exquisite food...a truly superb dining experience. ”

“ What a delight to find this place in Bargersville. Food is ok with their huge burger 57 a highlight. No energy though which is why it's a 4 star review not a 5 star review ”

“ Looking for a fun vibe? Knuckle Sandwich is the place! Tons of memorabilia on the walls and TV sets showing old shows like Gomer Pyle. Music on the jukebox has you singing along without even realizing it. After reading other yelp reviews, we decided to share the hubcap tenderloin. It was fully loaded with mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles and a huge beautiful bun. The tenderloin was hand pounded and was a little thin for my taste but it was still delicious. The fries were hot and crispy, a welcome change from cold or soggy fries. I also ordered a milkshake which was served in the metal cup. Other tables had great looking salads and burgers so we will be back. FYI cash prices are listed on the menu, a 3.5% of charge for credit card usage. ”

“ Love the atmosphere of walking in to the cool decor Our waitress was helpful with suggestions on what to order. She was on top of our needs. My huge tenderloin was seasoned and battered perfectly. The bun was also amazing as you can see it almost covered the tenderloin. I cut that in half which gave me 2 meals. Can't wait to go back. We were to full to try dessert but the milkshake and sundae looked mouthwatering ”

“ This is a new and neat little diner in Bargersville. They have an adequate parking lot that they share with the other businesses in the strip mall that it is located. The diner is a 50s/60s themed restaurant and has a ton of neat and nostalgic decorations. They have classic music playing outside and neat booth inside that is the shape of an old red Corvette. I think seating in that special booth is reserved for those crazy enough to try their food challenge that consists of eating 2-one pound burgers and 2 pounds of french fries. That seems easy enough, huh. They have a couple of televisions in the corners in the restaurant to watch, but they are not easy to view, or at least from where I was seated. The place was slammed packed when I was there. And this was the middle of the day. I had to wait 30 minutes. They just take your name and phone number, then call you when your table is ready. The staff there was awesome, even given how busy they were. They were very friendly, welcoming and attentive. The diner serves your typical diner food including burgers, fried chicken, fish, tenderloins, pizza, soups, salads, and breakfast food. I ordered the Big Booper BLT with a side of fries. It did not disappoint. It took only about 7 minutes for them to prepare and it was fresh, hot and tasty. As advertised, it was loaded with bacon. I highly recommend it. This is an awesome joint that deserves all of the hype that it gets and then some. It has a cool Fonzie type of vibe. It is just missing the bar seating. I highly recommend checking this place out. You will not be disappointed. ”